Sport in Vancouver and Newfoundland — A Reader’s Guide
Edition facts
The catalog record for Sport in Vancouver and Newfoundland — A Reader’s Guide provides practical reading context through 51,996 words, 3 hr 47 min estimated reading time, and 7 detected text sections.
The text analysis averages about 21.3 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.
Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Newfoundland and Labrador -- Description and travel,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.
Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.
How this score is calculated
- Description quality20 pts
- Title & short description10 pts
- Source metadata20 pts
- Text length15 pts
- Chapters / structure15 pts
- EPUB file integrity20 pts
Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.
Read the Text
River was strong--so July 17th found me starting for Montreal, where I arrived the same night and put up at the excellent Windsor Hotel.
Only a top sleeping berth on the Trans-Continental Express was available for the following night, and, as I desired a section--that is two berths, upper and lower--I had to wait till the evening of Sunday, the 19th, before I could start for Vancouver.
Leaving Montreal at 10.15 p.m., I arrived at Vancouver about noon on the 24th, having travelled straight through.
The Canadian Pacific Railway is probably the most extensively advertised line in the world. I cannot say it complied with modern requirements as regards convenience and comfort.
Every one knows the much-vaunted Pullman Car system of America--men and women in the same carriage, the only privacy being offered by drawing the curtains across the berths which are arranged in two long rows on either side of the car.
If you have a section of two berths, which is essential to comfort, you can stand upright in the lower berth to dress and undress, and put away your clothes where you can.
If you have only a single berth, you have to dress and undress as best you can, sitting in your berth.
On my first trip to Canada, I was only going as far as Mattawa, one night in the train, so contented myself with a single lower berth.
The upper berth was occupied by a very stout lady, who in descending in the morning, gave me an exhibition of understandings as unexpected by me as it was unintentional on her part.
The real advantage of a section, in taking the long Trans-Continental journey, is that when the berths are put up in the day-time, one has a nice compartment to oneself; that is, if the black porter does not condescend sometimes to occupy one of the seats, and only to move, on being politely requested to do so.
The sporting pamphlets of the Canadian Pacific Railway make a sportsman's mouth water. Here we have the paradise of the fisherman--there the Mecca of the sportsman.
It was certainly then disappointing, to say the least of it, to find in the Restaurant Car, that though passing through the paradise of the fisherman, two days out from Montreal, we were eating stale mackerel, and on the return journey when the sporting season was in full swing and duck and prairie hens were being brought in abundance to the car for sale--they were only purchased by the black porters for re-sale at Montreal at a handsome profit. None of them appeared at our table.
The food was indifferent and dear. Everything was "à la carte," and to dine moderately cost 1½ to 2 dollars, while a tiny glass of whisky, served in a specially constructed bottle of infinitesimal proportions, was charged at an exorbitant price.
Food in the car, without wine, beer or spirits, may be put down at 5 to 6 dollars a day, and I would recommend any one making the trip to stow away a bottle of good whisky in his suit-case, from which to fill his own flask for meals.
Travelling for six days and five nights continuously, one would have thought that some simple bathing arrangements would have been provided. A douche even would have been welcome. The lavatory and smoking-room were one and the same--five to six persons could find sitting accommodation, and four basins had to meet the washing requirements of the entire car.
I do not wish to be over critical, but I am glad to say I have met many Canadians who agree with me that the arrangements for the comfort of the passengers on the Canadian Pacific Railway are capable of improvement.
Very different, I was told, was the comfort to be found on the American Trans-Continental Line from Seattle via Chicago to New York. The train is provided with a bathroom, library and a barber's shop, while an American friend who recommended me to return by the American Express, assured me that the food left nothing to be desired.
When competition arises between the two Trans-Continental lines in Canada, the second of which is now being constructed, some improvements may be hoped for.
The scenery of the Rocky Mountains has so often been described, that I will not inflict my impressions at any length on my readers. It is certainly fine, but no part of it can in my opinion compare with that of the line from Lucerne to Milan via the St. Gothard, and what a difference in the engineering of the line and the speed of the trains. Accidents by derailing of ballast trains seemed fairly common. We saw one on our way across, and two engines which had toppled over the embankment marked the site of at least one other.
As regards the Rockies, it must be admitted that the effect of their real height is taken away by the gradual rise in level as one crosses the plains.
Calgary, where the mountains are first approached, stands at 3,428 feet above sea-level.
All things come to an end, and the morning of July 24th found us steaming into the city of Vancouver, glad that the weary journey was at last over.
The town of Vancouver is beautifully situated on the Mainland overlooking the Straits of Georgia.
I am glad, after my criticisms of the Canadian Pacific Railway, to testify to the comfort and moderate charges of the Canadian Pacific Railway Hotel at Vancouver.
A charming bedroom with bathroom attached cost only 5 dollars, all meals included. Excellent beer, locally brewed, was cheap, and a bottle of Californian Chianti, quite a drinkable wine, cost only a dollar, so there was nothing to complain of.
My waiter happened to be an Irishman, and he took quite a personal interest in my comfort, whispering into my ear in the most confidential manner the dishes of the day that he recommended as the best.
On a day's acquaintance, claiming me as a countryman, he confided to me his story. His father had been manager of a bank in Ireland, and he was sent abroad to settle in Canada.
Starting on a farm, and, according to his own story, doing well, a fire destroyed his house and farm implements. Drifting through various stages, he arrived at his present position, with which he seemed quite content. He was married, and lived outside the hotel. Fishing was his passion, and every spare moment was devoted to it.
He was really a most entertaining companion, with a keen sense of humour, and he made the meal-time pass very pleasantly, for he never ceased chatting.
A run by steamer to Seattle to see some friends, gave me a glimpse of Victoria and the exquisite scenery of the trip from Vancouver to Seattle.
At Vancouver I had the pleasure of making the acquaintance of Mr. Bryan Williams, the Provincial Game Warden of British Columbia, with whom I had been already in correspondence, and to whom I was indebted for much valuable assistance and advice.
A true sportsman, his heart is in his job, and if he only be given a free hand and adequate funds, the preservation of game in British Columbia will be in safe hands.
The licence, 100 dollars, is not a heavy one, but I think it might with justice be graduated, fixing one sum, say 50 dollars, for Vancouver Island, where only wapiti, an occasional bear and deer are found, and imposing the higher licence for the Mainland, to include moose, mountain sheep, goat, caribou and grizzly bear.
One would have thought that in the city of Vancouver, the centre of a great angling country, every requirement of the fisherman would have been found. The contrary was the case.
Fortunately I had brought my own fishing-tackle, for in the best sporting shop in the town I could not obtain a suitable spare fishing-line.
Rods, reels, lines, flies and baits were inferior in workmanship as compared to what one is accustomed at home.
I therefore strongly recommend any fisherman to bring all his tackle from home. In the case of rods, reels and lines, New York may have better, as I shall show when I come to discuss the question of tackle later on.
From the manager of the Bank of Montreal, to whom I had a letter of introduction, I met with great courtesy financially as well as socially, and I became free of the excellent Vancouver Club, so charmingly situated, and only regretted that my short stay prevented my availing myself more of its hospitality.
VANCOUVER TO THE CAMPBELL RIVER
VANCOUVER TO THE CAMPBELL RIVER
The morning of July 29th found me on board the _Queen City_, the small but most comfortable steamer of the Canadian Pacific Railway running north to the Campbell River and beyond.
The Captain was a delightful companion, patriotic to a degree, and regretting what he considered the neglect shown by the Old Country to the Dominion of Canada, when American and Canadian interests were at issue.
The steamer was well found and well managed, while the Captain's skill in approaching our various stopping-places, often dangerous coves with no lights, at any time of the night and in any weather, was to me a continual source of admiration. I travelled with him three times, and never wish for a more charming host or a Captain that inspired more confidence as a navigator.
We arrived at the Campbell River Pier at the unearthly hour of 1 a.m. The proprietor, however, was on the pier waiting with lanterns to show us the way up to the Willows Hotel, where I was to spend a happy month.
The Willows Hotel, beautifully situated on the Valdez Straits within a few yards of the sea, is all that a sportsman could desire. Clean, well-furnished bedrooms, a bathroom and quite a decent table, all for the moderate sum of 2 dollars a day.
The proprietor did not quite realize the fact that the majority of the guests came for the fishing, and not for the food.
The lady who directed the establishment seemed to think the latter the more important.
The breakfast bell rang at 6 a.m., and breakfast was served from 6 to 8 a.m. Lunch or dinner from 12 to 2 p.m., and supper from 6 to 8 p.m.
Woe betide the guest who broke the rules of the house as regards the hours, for he was expected to lose his meal.
In those glorious autumn evenings when it was light up to 10 o'clock, the manageress forgot that a keen fisherman might stay out till 9 or even 10, if the fish were taking.
Dinner he could not expect, but a cold supper, if ordered beforehand, might have been laid out in the dining-room. Nor could attendance be looked for; servants were few and overworked, and it was but natural they should like to go to bed at 10 o'clock, or be free to wander in the woods or along the foreshore with the special young man of the moment.
By making love to the manageress and the Chinese cook, I generally succeeded in finding something to eat if I was late, but I often had to forage for myself in the kitchen, and on one occasion came back to find a plate of very indifferent sandwiches laid out for supper.
Morning tea in one's bedroom was prohibited. I should therefore advise any one addicted to the habit of early morning tea, to provide himself with a "Thermos" bottle, and fill it overnight--besides which, if very enthusiastic, a start might sometimes be made at 4 a.m., when a cup of hot tea and a biscuit make all the difference to one's feelings of comfort.
The hotel was a strange mixture of civilization and discomfort.
We had written menus of which I give a specimen below, but I had to grease my own boots and wash my own clothes, until I found an Indian squaw in the adjoining village who for an exorbitant charge relieved me of my washing, though I greased my boots till the end of my stay.
_Soup._ Purée of Split Pea.
_Fish._ Baked Salmon (Spanish). Boiled Cod. Lobster Sauce.
_Entrées._ Beef Hot Pot. Pig's Head à la Printanière. Macaroni au Gratin.
_Boiled._ Boiled Ox Tongue. Kipper Sauce. Boiled Ham.
_Roast._ Roast Beef. Horse-radish. Roast Pork. Apple Sauce. Roast Mutton. Jelly.
_Salad._ Sliced Beets. Fish Salad.
_Vegetables._ Boiled Mashed Potatoes. Green Peas.
_Dessert._ Snow Pudding. Peach Pie. Apple Pie. Stewed Rhubarb.
The drawback to the hotel was the logging camp in the neighbourhood.
The bar of the hotel was about fifty yards from the hotel itself, in a separate building, and on Saturday night many of the loggers came dropping in to waste the earnings of the week. Drunkenness on these occasions was far too common, and till the small hours of the morning the sound of revelry from the bar was not conducive to a good night's rest.
Some of the characters who frequented the bar were weird in the extreme, and when fairly "full"--as the local expression was--the hotel was not inviolate to them. One who particularly interested me might have been taken out of one of Fenimore Cooper's novels. My acquaintance with him was made on the hotel verandah. With a friendly feeling born of much whisky, he placed his arm on my shoulder, and assured me that although if he had his rights he would be a Lord, he did not disdain the acquaintanceship of a commoner like myself; in fact, that he had seldom seen a man to whom he had taken such a fancy, or with whom he would more willingly tramp the woods, if I would only give him the pleasure of my company in his trapper's hut some few miles inland. His suggestion that our friendship should be cemented by an adjournment to the bar did not meet with the ready acceptance he expected, which evidently disappointed him, for he could not grasp the fact that any one living could refuse a drink.
Poor "Lord B.," as he was called, was only his own enemy. As I always addressed him "My Lord," which he took quite seriously, we became quite pals.
A trapper and prospector by profession, he had a fair education, and when sober was a shrewd man of the local world, which confined itself to prospecting for minerals and cruising timber claims.
Persistently drunk for two or three days at a time, he would suddenly sober down, put a pack on his back which few men could carry, and disappear into the woods to his lonely log cabin, only to return in a few days ready for a fresh spree. At least, this was his life while I stayed at the hotel, for in one month he appeared three times.
No doubt during the winter, when occupied with his traps, he could neither afford the time nor the money for an hotel visit.
He was wizened in appearance and lightly built, but as hard as nails. Dishevelled to look at when on the spree, as soon as it was all over he became a different character, appearing in neat, clean clothes, and full of reminiscences of backwoods life. He was always a subject of interest to me, and, poor fellow, like many others on the west coast, only his own enemy.
Another frequenter of the bar had been on the Variety stage in London, and his step-dancing when fairly primed with whisky was something to see and remember.
We were a pleasant party at the hotel. Some came only for the fishing, some _en route_ for Alaska or elsewhere on the Mainland for the coming shooting season, others returning from sporting expeditions in far lands.
We had J. G. Millais, the well-known naturalist and author of the most charming book ever written on Newfoundland, bound for Alaska in search of record moose and caribou.
Colonel Atherton, who, starting from India, had recently crossed Central Asia and obtained some splendid trophies, the photographs of which made us all envious.
F. Grey Griswold from New York, of tarpon fame, come to try his luck with the tyee salmon, and good luck it was, which such a good sportsman deserved.
Mr. Daggett, an enthusiastic angler from Salt Lake City, who took plaster casts of his fish, and was apparently an old habitué of the hotel.
Powell and a young undergraduate friend Stern, also bound for Alaska, just starting on the glorious life of sport, with little experience--that was to come--but who with the tyee salmon were as good as any of us, and whose keenness spoke well for the future.
It was curious that in such a small community three of us, the Colonel, Millais and I, had fished in Iceland, and many interesting chats we had about the sport in that fascinating island.
As the sun went down, the boats began to come in, and all interest was concentrated on the beach, where the fish were brought to be weighed on the very inaccurate steelyard set up on a shaky tripod by the hotel proprietor.
Any one reading Sir Richard Musgrave's article in the _Field_, would be led to believe that the fishing was in the Campbell River itself.
Whatever it may have been in his time, the river is now practically useless from the fisherman's point of view. This is due to the logging camp in the vicinity, for the river for about a mile from its mouth is practically blocked with great rafts of enormous logs. The logs are discharged into the river with a roar and a crash, enough to frighten every fish out of the water; the rafts when formed are towed down to Vancouver.
The river no doubt was a fine one till the logging business was established, and it is possible that late in the autumn fish may run up to spawn--but during the entire month of August, I personally never saw a salmon of any kind in the river itself.
Flowing out of the Campbell lake a few miles away, its course is very rapid, and it falls into the sea about one and a half miles north of the hotel.
The falls, impassable for fish, can be visited in a long day's walk from the hotel. The distance is not great, but the impenetrable character of the Vancouver forest makes the walk a very fatiguing one. It is most regrettable that no track has been cleared along the banks, to enable the water to be fished and to give access to the falls, which I am told are very beautiful.
I endeavoured to reach them by the river, but spent most of the day up to my waist in water, hauling my boat through the rapids, and then only got half-way and saw no fish.
Below the falls, there is a fine deep pool in which Mr. Layard, who described his trip in the _Field_, states he saw the great tyee salmon "in droves." He does not say at what time of the year he visited the falls or whether the logging camp then existed. It must have been late in the season, for he describes the swarms of duck and wild geese, the seals that were a perfect plague, the sea-lions that were seen several times, and the bear, panther (cougar), deer and willow grouse in the immediate vicinity of the hotel.
I can only give my personal experiences during the month of August.
Forgetting that the shooting season did not begin till September 1st, I took with me 300 cartridges and never fired a shot, nor did I see anything to shoot at. A few duck were occasionally seen flying down the Straits between Vancouver and Valdez Island, but the seals, sea-lions and other game described by Mr. Layard were conspicuous by their absence in the month of August. No doubt later on, in September and October, different conditions may prevail, but August is the month _par excellence_ for the fisherman and he may leave his gun behind.
The tide runs up the river for about 800 yards from the mouth, where there was some water free from logs and rafts. Some good sport with the cut-throat trout was to be had, more especially at spring tides.
My best catch was fourteen weighing 16½ lb.
The water was intensely clear; careful wading, long casting and very fine tackle were necessary to obtain any sport.
The cut-throat trout appeared to me to resemble the sea trout in its habits, hanging about the mouth of the river and running up with the tide, many falling back on the turn of the tide, but a certain number running up and remaining in the upper reaches.
The largest I killed, 5 lb., was immediately in front of the hotel, in the sea itself, one and a half miles from the river, and he took a spoon intended for a tyee salmon.
Sir John Rogers opens his account with a specific trigger: an article in The Field describing a seventy-pound salmon caught on the Campbell River. That single piece of journalism set him on a course to Vancouver Island, and his narrative retains the diary's immediacy—dates, distances, and daily setbacks are recorded without embellishment. The prose is functional, often blunt: a bear encounter is described as “as bad a moment as I have ever experienced,” and a missed shot is blamed on a telescope sight left at the wrong range. Rogers does not pose as a literary sportsman; he writes as a man who wants the next hunter to avoid his mistakes.
The Diary as a Technical Manual
Rogers frames his book as “simply a transcription of my rough diary,” and the text bears that out. He records the weight of fish, the condition of rivers, and the performance of equipment with the precision of a field notebook. When he misses a bear, he notes that he had left his coat with spare cartridges behind and that the telescope sight was “screwed up to 300 yards” when the animal was closer. These details are not dramatic flourishes; they are operational notes. The reader learns that crossing a creek in flood on “rough boulders” is “as bad as it well could be,” and that a wounded bear in dense undergrowth is too dangerous to follow. The book’s value lies in this granular, unromantic record of what worked and what did not.
Voice and the Absence of Self-Dramatization
Rogers rarely casts himself as a hero. When he fires his last cartridge and the wounded bear walks toward him, he writes: “There was I without a cartridge and a wounded bear apparently walking on top of me. I lay quite quietly behind my rock.” The understatement is characteristic. He does not describe his fear; he reports his position and the bear’s movement. Later, when his companion Thomson wants to follow the bear into the brush, Rogers refuses but records Thomson’s persistence. The narrative voice is that of a leader making calculated decisions, not a hunter boasting of close calls. The drama emerges from the situation, not from self-praise.
Landscape as Obstacle and Spectacle
Rogers’ descriptions of terrain are functional but occasionally vivid. After a night of rain and sleet, he notes that “the rain had now turned to snow, which was lying as low down as the level of the camp.” The march that follows is a catalogue of difficulties: the creek is “a roaring torrent,” the boulders are slippery, and everything is “sodden.” Yet he also pauses for a view: “Our last view of the valley, before we entered the forest, was superb. The rain had cleared away, a bright sun was breaking through the heavy clouds.” These moments are rare and therefore striking. The landscape is primarily an obstacle to be managed, but Rogers acknowledges its beauty in passing, without sentimentality.
The Role of Local Knowledge and Companions
Rogers does not travel alone. He mentions guides and companions by name—Kirby, Lansdown, Thomson—and their actions are integral to the narrative. Thomson is the one who “would not give him up” and crawls through the cover to track the wounded bear. The guides skin the goat and bring in the head. Rogers presents himself as dependent on their skills, and the diary records their contributions without fuss. The book is as much about the network of people who enable these expeditions as it is about the author’s own prowess. This collective effort is a quiet thread throughout the text.
Readers approaching Sport in Vancouver and Newfoundland should expect a practical, unadorned narrative. Rogers’ diary format means that events are presented in sequence, with little retrospection or thematic organization. The book rewards those who read for specific detail—the weight of a salmon, the behavior of a wounded bear, the condition of a trail after rain. It is not a meditation on nature or sport, but a record of what one man did and saw, and it is best read as such.
I keep thinking about that 1912 diary—how carefully Rogers noted the weight of a salmon, the exact bend of a river, and what it meant to wait for hours in cold rain. That quiet, patient attention to place feels echoed in An Account of Two Voyages to New-England, Made During the Years 1638, 1663 — Edition Insights, where a different century’s traveler also paused to notice small, stubborn details of the land. Something about that steadiness stays with me.
How did this book work for you?
Your answers remain private and are stored only in this browser.
Lucas Adams
1 week ago